THE AGE OF THE EARTH
ANDYSEZ Number 30 
[Journal 33, December 1998, pp 43–50]

This ANDYSEZ is going to be a little bit of a pot-boiler. Please let me know what topics you would like discussed. 

Lots of reports, EISs and reviews cross my desk – and I often see that various NPWS officers have encountered a term such as “Jurassic” and consequently  insert a marginal note asking for the age in years to be inserted. I seriously doubt that amending the documents to say “Jurassic Period (195-135 million years ago)” helps their comprehension of what is meant by “Jurassic”. Millions of years are a fairly nebulous concept to those who life for +/-70 years (or whatever the current figure is). Perhaps we can conceive that our parents lived for, say 20 years before they produced us and that we understand something about their life before us – and that we can see some sort of program for our kids extending across a similar period. Let’s be bold and say that we have some sort of time perspective across 150 years – we will call them lifetimes.

This period (150 years) is just 0.015% of one million years. The Jurassic started 195 million years ago, lasted 40 million and finished 155 million years ago. Using our 150 years, the Jurassic started 1.3 million lifetimes ago, lasted about 470,000 lifetimes and finished about 433,333 lifetimes before present. Do these sorts of juggling with numbers make them any more understandable – I don’t think so. But there are sure lots of them - we will come back to this point later.
 

Let’s try an analogy (apologies to all non-eastern State readers and to those from our geological possession across the Tasman Sea).

THE VASTNESS OF GEOLOGIC TIME

To comprehend the vastness of geologic time think of the following analogy. If the distance from Perth to Sydney (3,291 km) is taken to be equivalent to the age of the Earth, then, traveling from west to east, you would reach the beginning of the Cambrian only 421 km from Sydney, near Wagga Wagga; the earliest evidence of man occurs right in the heart of the city, at Central Railway Station, 3.65 km from the journey's end at the southern end of the Sydney Harbour Bridge; the arrival of the Aboriginal people around 35 metres from the Bridge and the time of European settlement in Australia is less than a handspan (<150 mm; after BMR 1990 ).

To a geologist the term “Jurassic” means a time period between two other periods (the younger, the Cretaceous Period, and the older, the Triassic Period). All these “Periods” together form the “Mesozoic Era”. Geologists have divided the lifetime of our Planet, Earth, into four groups of time slabs termed Eon, Era, Period and Epoch respectively. How all of these fit together is shown in the following table. Note that you will find many versions of geologic time scales with differing intervals and ages - these things are subject to change and re-interpretation. The Australian Geological Survey Organisation and the Geological Society of Australia produce some nice time scales on card - contact AGSO sales on 02 6249 9642 or sales@agso.gov.au. Visit the site on http://www.agso.gov.au. The ages in brackets in the table are from the AGSO card - a more recent interpretation of geologic ages.

A GEOLOGICAL TIME SCALE

Now lets see what these huge numbers mean to us short-lived humans. Using our 150 year “lifetimes”:

I have repeatedly pointed out in previous ANDYSEZs that one shouldn’t extrapolate backwards using current rates of stalactite development or erosion of surfaces. This is because rates have changed dramatically in response to climate change, atmospheric composition and lots of other things and over the long run today’s rates may be completely nonsensical. But I am now going to do some extrapolating to show how slow rates can produce big effects through time.

Consider a stalagmite accumulating at between 0.01 and 0.5 mm per year (these seem to be fairly reasonable figures based on work around the world although Trevor Shaw tabulated a number of rates that had a average value of 3.7 mm per year but a range from 0.007 to 40.09 mm per year - clearly one has to be very cautious - there is so much inter-site variability!). But using the more conservative rates if we allow say, 10,000 and 100,000 years (again not unreasonable ages for an individual cave chamber) to elapse we get the following accumulations:

What about erosion, I hear you cry? Let’s take some surface lowering examples and run them across time too. But we will again take some measured values and extend them across similar periods - and longer.

What about continental drift? We will tackle this in a slightly different way. Antarctica and Australia separated about 120 million years ago - they are now about 3,800 kilometres apart. What might be the relative rate of movement between the two continents?

(3,800*1000*100)/120,000,000 = ~3.2 centimetres a year!
Australia is said to be colliding with New Guinea at a rate of around 6 centimetres per year - “around the rate that your finger nails grow”. This latter statement shows that slow rates that we can “see” daily, when taken with even moderate amounts of time, can lead to big things if let alone.

But, I must caution again about extrapolating across time - too many of the parameters change through time. Play with numbers, by all means, but don’t let the “Old Black Magic” (I am listening to “The Very Best of Glenn Miller” as I type!) of numbers hypnotise you - they are not necessarily facts.

We might come back to continental drift and plate tectonics in later ANDYSEZs. But I had better explain my crack about our geologic possession across the Tasman. 

Originally all the southern continents and India formed a supercontinent named Gondwana which in turn was a large fragment of a former supercontinent called Pangea.  Around 120 Ma, in Early Cretaceous times, Australia and Antarctica began to split apart with Australia moving north. Australia has wandered around the surface of the globe and has occupied both polar and equatorial positions as it drifted around which helps account for the differing climates in the past. Changes in sea level (regressions = falling; transgressions = rising) and climate change account for many of the changes in the geologic record that we see preserved today. Of course climatic and sea level change effects are also modified by tectonic processes - these are the movements of continents, sea-floor rifting, mountain building, faulting and folding and so on.

Australia has had an extremely long and diverse history. The continent is made up of a series of “blocks”  -  very old crystalline rocks which form the basement of the continent. As these blocks eroded Australia grew towards the east as sediments eroded from the blocks and were deposited in troughs formed by the rifting apart of the continental plate. Volcanoes developed in the rifting margin and contributed to the continent building. The rifting and building continues today in that part, geologically, of Australia called New Zealand - so there!

CONSOLIDATED REFERENCES AND FURTHER READING
AHARON P 1988 A stable isotope study of magnesites from the Rum Jungle uranium field, Australia: Implications for the origin of strata-bound massive magnesites. Chemical Geology 69 127-145.
ATKINSON TC and SMITH DI 1976 The Erosion of Limestones, Chapter 5 in FORD TD and CULLINGFORD CHD (eds) The Science of Speleology, Academic Press, London
BAKER WE 1986 Humic substances and their role in the solubilization and transport of metals. In: CARLISLE D, BERRY WL, KAPLAN IR and WATTERSON JR (eds) Mineral exploration: Biological systems and organic matter. Rubey Volume 5, Prentice-Hall.
BARRY K 1987 Beware the sweats by night: A lethargic geologist, Australian Family Physician 16 (4) 478.
BASTIAN L 1964 Morphology and development of caves in the Southwest of Western Australia. Helictite, 2:105-119.
BELL MW 1972 Problems in the growth of speleothems, Part 3: Observation and explanation of helictites, Spelograffitti, 9(5)81-92
BUSENBERG E and PLUMMER LN 1982 The kinetics of dissolution of dolomite in CO2 - H2O systems at 1.5 to 65°C and 0 to 1 atm pCO2. American Journal of Science 282:45-78.
CAROL EM 1988 Where’s the histo? Histoplasma in Chillagoe Caves area, North Queensland, Australia, Helictite 26(2) 26-36.
COX G, JAMES JM, LEGGETT KEA and OSBORNE RAL 1989 Cyano-bacterially deposited speleothems: Subaerial stromatolites, Geomicrobiological Journal 7:245-252
DAWKINS W Boyd 1874 Cave Hunting, researches on the evidence of caves respecting the early inhabitants of Europe, London, Macmillan, 455pp.
DWYER P 1970 in SPRENT JK (ed) Mount Etna Caves, University of Queensland Speleological Society.
FOLK RL, ROBERTS HH and MOORE CH 1973 Black phytokarst from Hell, Cayman Islands, British West Indies, Bulletin of the Geological Society of America 84:1247-60
FORD DC and WILLIAMS PW 1989 Karst Geomorphology and Hydrology, Unwin Hyman, London, 601 pp
FORD TD 1976 The Geology of Caves, Chapter 2 in FORD TD and CULLINGFORD CHD (eds) The Science of Speleology, Academic Press, London & New York
FREY D 1974 Open letter on Histoplasmosis, Australian Speleological Federation Newsletter 64:15-16 
GILLIESON D 1996 Caves: Processes, Development, Management, Blackwell, Oxford
GILLIESON DS and SMITH DI (eds) 1989 Resource Management in limestone landscapes: international perspectives, Special Publication No. 2, Department. of Geography and Oceanography, University College, Australian Defence Force Academy, Canberra
HALBERT EJM 1982 Evaluation of Carbon dioxide and Oxygen Data in Cave Atmospheres Using the Gibbs Triangle and the Cave Air Index, Helictite 20(2)60-68
HARDEN TJ and HUNT PJ 1985. Histoplasmosis and Australian Cave Environments, Helictite 23(1)23-26
HARMON R S, ATKINSON TC and ATKINSON JJ 1983 The mineralogy of Castlegard Cave, Columbia Icefields, Alberta, Canada. Arctic and Alpine Research 15(4): 503-16.
HILL CA and FORTI P 1986 Cave Minerals of the World, National Speleological Society, Huntsville, Alabama, (2nd edn), 238 pp.
HILL AL 1984 The origin of the Kelly Hill Caves, Kangaroo Island, South Australia Helictite, 22:6-10. [written 1957, published posthumously with a note by Joe Jennings]
HOWARTH FG and STONE FD 1990 Elevated Carbon Dioxide Levels in Bayliss Cave, Australia: Implications for the evolution of obligate caves species, Pacific Science, 44(3)207-2 1 8
HUNT PJ, HARDEN TJ, HIBBINS M, PRITCHARD RC, MUIR DB and GARDNER FJ 1984  Histoplasma capsulatum Isolation from an Australian cave environment and from a patient, Medical Journal of Australia 141:280-283.
IRWIN D 1988 Breathing Apparatus for use in Foul Air Caves, Proceedings of the Seventeenth Biennial Conference of the Australian. Speleological. Federation., pp 126-130
ISBISTER J, ELLIOTT M and NOGRADY S 1976. Histoplasmosis: an outbreak occurring among young men who visited one cave, Medical Journal of Australia 2: 243-248.
JAKUCS I 1977 Morphogenetics of Karst Regions, Adam Hilger, Bristol
JAMES J & DYSON J 1981 CO2 in Caves.  Caving International Magazine 13:54-59.
JAMES JM 1977 Carbon dioxide in the Cave Atmosphere, Transactions of the British Cave Research Association 4(4)419-429.
JAMES JM PAVEY AJ & ROGERS AF 1975 Foul Air and the Resulting Hazard to Cavers, Transactions of the British Cave Research Association 2(2)79-88.
JENNINGS JN 1985 Karst Geomorphology, Blackwell, Oxford, 293 pp.
JENNINGS JN 1968 Syngenetic karst in Australia. In: JENNINGS JN and WILLIAMS PW (eds) Contributions to the Study of Karst. Research School of Pacific Studies, Australian National  University. Occasional Paper 5. pp 41-110.
KERMODE LO 1980 Cave Corrosion by Tourists, Proceedings of the Third Australasian Conference on Cave Tourism and Management, Mount Gambier, pp 97-104.
LEE JD 1991 Concise inorganic chemistry, 4th edition.  Chapman and Hall.
LEWIS WC 1974  Histoplasmosis in caves, National Speleological Society News 32(2) 22-26. 
LICHON MJ 1992 The phototropic phytospeleothems of Moss Palace, Mole Creek, Tasmania, Helictite 30(1)8-10.
MARKER ME 1973  Some aspects of the magnesium problem in karst weathering, with special reference to the northeastern Transvaal, South Africa. Transactions of the Cave Research Group of Great Britain 15(1): 9-17.
McCALLUM WS 1990 Magnesite deposits in South Australia. In: HUGHES FE (ed) Geology of the Mineral Deposits of Australia and Papua New Guinea. Australian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy, Melbourne.
MERRILL GP 1868 On the Formation of Stalactites and Gypsum Incrustations in Caves, Proceedings of the US National Museum, XVII (1894):77-81.
MOSES CA, SPATE AP, SMITH DI and GREENAWAY MA 1995 Limestone weathering in Eastern Australia, Part 2: Process study, Earth Surface Processes  & Landforms, 20:501-514
NPWS 1983 Harvesting and Rehabilitation of Jounama Pine Plantation, Kosciusko National Park - Environmental Impact Statement, NPWS and Forestry Commission, Sydney
OSBORNE RAL 1981 Towards an Air Quality Standard for Tourist Caves: Studies of Carbon Dioxide Enriched Atmospheres in Gaden-Coral Cave, Wellington Caves, NSW, Helictite 19(2)48-56
OSBORNE RAL 1990 Carbon dioxide in Tourist Caves - A Review, Proceedings of the Fifth Australasian  Cave Tourism & Management Conference, Lakes Entrance, pp 43-47
PICKNETT RG 1972  The pH of calcite solutions with and without magnesium carbonate present, and the implications concerning rejuvenated aggressiveness. Transactions of the Cave Research Group of Great Britain  14(2):141-150.
PICKNETT RG and STENNER RD 1978 Enhanced calcite solubility in dilute magnesium carbonate solutions. Transactions of the British Cave Research Association 5(1):47-54.
PRINZ W 1908 Les cristallisations des grottes de Belgique, Nouv. Mem. Soc. Belge. Geol., de Palaeontologie et Hydrologie, 4.
SADLER BS, MAUGER GW and STOKES RA 1988 The water resource implications of a drying climate in south-west Western Australia, pp 296-311 in PEARMAN GI (ed) Greenhouse: Planning for Environmental Change, CSIRO, Melbourne
SHANNON CHC 1993 Karst values of the proposed mining sites for ochre extraction and their environs, Savage River, Tasmania, in: SAVAGE RESOURCES 1993. Development proposal and environmental management plan to operate a mine and benefication plants for the production of pigment at Savage River and on the northwest coast. Unpublished report, Savage Resources Ltd.
SHARPLES C 1997 Karst geomorphology and values of the Tarkine. Limestone, dolomite and magnesite karst systems of the Arthur-Pieman region of Tasmania. Report to the Australian Heritage Commission and the Tasmania Conservation Trust Inc.
SMITH DI, GREENAWAY MA, MOSES C and SPATE AP 1995 Limestone weathering in Eastern Australia, Part 1: Erosion rates, Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, 20:451-463
SOLOMON SB, LANGROO R, PEGGIE JR, LYONS RG AND JAMES JM 1996 Occupational Exposure to Radiation in Australian Tourist Caves: An Australia-wide Study of Radon Levels, Final Report of Worksafe Australia Research Grant (93/0436), Australian Radiation Laboratory, ARL/TR 119
STEVENSON WJ AND HUGHES KL 1988  Synopsis of Zoonoses in Australia, 2nd ed., Canberra, Australian Government Publishing, pp 95-98
VILES H A 1987 Blue-green algae and terrestrial limestone weathering on Aldabara Atoll: an SEM and light microscope study, Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, 12:319-330
WATTS HOLDINGS PTY LTD 1988 Watts What in Augusta Area, Western Australia, 1998 Edition, 12 pp
WHITE WB 1976 Cave Minerals and Speleothems, Chapter 8, in FORD TD and CULLINGFORD CHD (eds) The Science of Speleology, Academic Press, London, 593 pp
WHITE S 1994 Speleogenesis in aeolean calcarenite: a case study in western Victoria. Environmental Geology, 23:248-255.
WHITTEN W K 1992  Reflections on caving, chest clinics and Histoplasma capsulatum: a case study, Journal of Occupational Health and Safety - Australia-New Zealand, 8(6)535-541.

More ANDY-SEZ